BUFFALO BILL'S RESTAURANT & TAVERN

MAKE A RESERVATION
Buffalo Bill’s RESTAURANT & TAVERN is a SHOW LOW FAVORITE.
SEE OUR MENU BELOW THE PHOTO GALLERY.
Restaurant & Tavern Hours 
Monday – Sunday:
11:00 am to 8:00 pm
 

APPETIZERS

Burnt Ends
16.00

Melted Bleu Cheese / Spicy & Sweet BBQ Sauce / Green Onion Curls / Radish Garnish

Cheese Curd Poutine
14.00

Beer Battered White Cheddar Cheese Curds Served /Ranch

Buffalo Chicken Dip
18.00

Served with Bleu Cheese / Green Onions / Warm Tortilla Chips / Celery & Carrots

Cheese Curds
13.00

Beer Battered White Cheddar Cheese Curds Served with Marinara

Chicken Wings
16.00

Tossed in choice of: Buffalo / BBQ Mango Habanero / Sweet Chili Sauce / Ranch / Carrots / Celery

BLACKENED SHRIMP
15.00

Southwest Succotash / Bacon / Jalapenos / Corn Black Beans / Green Chilis / Comeback Sauce / Grilled Bread

CHICKEN ARTICHOKE FLATBREAD
18.00

Pesto / Rotisserie Chicken / Artichokes Goat Cheese / Balsamic Glaze

BURGERS & SANDWICHES

Featuring buns and bread from Baked in Pinetop. Pick one side.

AZ CHEESEBURGER 1/2 lb
18.00
BISON CHEESEBURGER
24.00
BBQ PULLED PORK SANDWICH
17.00

House Smoked Pork / BBQ Sauce / Coleslaw

BBQ BRISKET SANDWICH
19.00

House Smoked Brisket with BBQ Sauce

THE GUNSLINGER
25.00

Wagyu Beef / Bourbon Bacon Jam / Swiss Cheese / Arugula

COWBOY DIP
20.00

Shaved Roast Beef on Griddled Rye Pepper Jack / Creamy Horseradish / Roasted Green Chili / Sauteed Mushrooms

WHITE MOUNTAIN CHEESESTEAK
19.00

Shaved Prime Rib / Pepper Jack / Onions / Bell Peppers / Served with Comeback Sauce on a Hoagie Roll

SOUTHWEST CHICKEN SANDWICH
18.00

Marinated Chicken Breast / Pepper Jack / Roasted Green Chili / Comeback Sauce

** BURGER & SANDWICH ADDITIONS
2.00 each

bacon / sautéed onions / sautéed mushrooms / green chili / jalapeños / Gluten free bun $3

Entrees

Choose 2 sides

BBQ BABY BACK RIBS
30.00H | 38.00 F

Half or Full

1/3 LB BBQ BRISKET
26.00
1/3 LB BBQ PULLED PORK
25.00
SMOKED SAUSAGE (2)
19.00

Jalapeno Cheddar

ROTISSERIE CHICKEN – HALF
22.00

Pick One: Cajun, Lemon Herb, Mango Habanero Glaze, Sweet Chili Glaze

RIBEYE 14 oz
44.00
FILET 8 OZ
46.00
SALMON 7OZ
34.00

Mango Habanero Glaze with Mango Salsa

BBQ PLATTER
60.00

¼ LB BBQ Brisket ¼ LB Pulled Pork 1 Smoked Sausage ½ Rack Baby Back Ribs ¼ Rotisserie Chicken Pickles/Onions / Bourbon Beans / Mac & Cheese / Coleslaw NO SUBSTITUTIONS

COUNTRY FRIED STEAK
23.00
SPAGHETTI BOLOGNESE
20.00

House Made Bolognese, Shaved Parmesan Cheese, Grilled Garlic Bread (Does not include side)

** Additions

Sautéed Onions +5 , Sautéed Mushrooms +5, Grilled Shrimp +9

CORN COBETTE
4.00
ASPARAGUS
8.00
CREAMY COLESLAW
4.00
BOURBON BAKED BEANS
6.00
FRENCH FRIES
5.00

Add Loaded +4

ONION RINGS
6.00
MASHED POTATOES
5.00

Add Country Gravy +2

BAKED POTATO
8.00

Add Loaded +4, Add BBQ Brisket or BBQ Pulled Pork +8

MAC & CHEESE
8.00

Add Burnt Ends +6

SOUTHWEST MAC & CHEESE
21.00

Bacon/Green Chili / Jalapeños Choose Blackened Chicken Breast or Blackened Shrimp (Docs not include sides)

BLACKENED ROCKFISH & SHRIMP
27.00

Southwest Wild Rice / Creole Sauce / Crispy Onions

PIZZA & FLATBREAD

Home-made Crust. Gluten Free Crust +2. Topping Options: Pepperoni, Sausage, Bacon, Chicken, Tomatoes, Black Olives, Bell Peppers, Green Chilis, Jalapenos, Onions, Mushrooms, Extra Cheese

BUILD YOUR OWN PIZZA
20.00

PICK 3 TOPPINGS - Pepperoni/Sausage / Bacon / Chicken / Tomatoes / Black Olives / Bell Peppers / Green Chilis / Jalapenos / Onions / Mushrooms / Extra Cheese

CHEESE PIZZA
17.00
PEPPERONI PIZZA
18.00
HICKOCK PIZZA
20.00

Sausage / Bacon / Green Chili

BBQ CHICKEN PIZZA
20.00

House Rotisserie Chicken Red Onions / Cilantro / BBQ Sauce / Mozzarella Cheese

SUPREME PIZZA
21.00

Pepperoni / Sausage / Mushrooms / Bell Peppers / Black Olives / Onions

MARGHERITA PIZZA
18.00

Tomatoes/Fresh Mozzarella/Basil

soup & salads

Salad Additions: Add Rotisserie* or Crispy Chicken +5, Steak +7, Salmon +9

CAESAR SALAD
10.00 SM | 13.00 LG
HOUSE SALAD
10.00 SM | 13.00 LG

Mixed Greens & Romaine / Tomatoes / Cucumbers / Cheese Blend / Croutons / Tossed in House Made Ranch Dressing

CHOPPED SALAD
15.00

Mixed Greens & Romaine / Hard Boiled Egg / Bacon / Goat Cheese / Tossed in House Made Ranch Dressing

TAVERN SALAD
17.00

Mixed Greens & Romaine Spiced Pecans / Dried Cranberries / Bleu Cheese Crumbles / Tossed in Prickly Pear Vinaigrette

SOUTHWEST CORN CHOWDER
7.00 C | 9.00 B

Roasted Corn, Black Beans, Bacon

SOUP OF THE DAY
7.00 C | 9.00 B
CAPRESE SALAD
17.00

Mixed Greens & Romaine /Spiced Pecans/Dried Cranberries / Bleu Cheese Crumbles / Tossed in Prickly Pear Vinaigrette

SIDES

CORN COBETTE
4.00
ASPARAGUS
8.00
CREAMY COLESLAW
4.00
BOURBON BAKED BEANS
6.00
FRENCH FRIES
5.00

Add Loaded +4

ONION RINGS
6.00
MASHED POTATOES
5.00

Add Country Gravy +2

BAKED POTATO
8.00

Add Loaded +4, Add BBQ Brisket or BBQ Pulled Pork +8

MAC & CHEESE
8.00

Add Burnt Ends +6

Dessert

S’Mores Peanut Butter Flatbread
12.00
White Chocolate Raspberry Cheesecake
12.00
4 Layer Carrot Cake
12.00
5 Layer Chocolate Cake
12.00
Top